Webcams for astro-imaging Page 2

 
 < Page 1
Webcams compared
The Creative Video IM Pro camera costs about £15 from Argos in a plain box, or about £25 from PC World in a fancy box.  I chose it because it was reputed to work at low light levels, which indeed it does, though not as low as the ToUcam, as the following tests made under dim room lighting show.

PCLIM ProToucam
PCL 100kCreative Video IM ProPhilips ToUcam 740
As well as being most sensitive, the ToUcam was the easiest to control, and gave the sharpest results. The image made with the PCL 100k was taken through the Philips lens. All three images are stacks of 100 frames and were auto-processed using Registax.  The following images were given a little processing using Picasa, which shows that the PCL image was very noisy.

PCL test 1IM Pro test 1Toucam test 1
PCL 100KCreative Video IM ProPhilips ToUcam 740

So while the very cheap webcam is capable of giving reasonable results with a bright subject, such as the Moon, you need more sensitivity for planetary imaging. The Video IM Pro might have been capable of giving acceptable results, I found it  very hard to control under low-light conditions. The image would vary in exposure and colour balance unpredictably, even when auto controls were turned off. The ToUcam, however, has separate controls for gain, brightness and frame rate and can be controlled very easily.

The PCL and Creative webcams have smaller chips than the ToUcam, which means that it is harder to get a small planet on to them. However, the smaller chips do mean that the image scale is larger than with the ToUcam.

It would be very useful to know of another webcam which is widely available, has a removable 12 mm lens, and gives good quality results, but without buying every one on the market this is tricky.  Several webcams have been reported on over the years, but many of them are no longer available or at least not in the UK.  The Logitech Fusion (£45) is one camera that has been shown to give good results, but it requires some modification before it can be used.

Page 3 >

Back to home page